Wednesday, May 1, 2013

Bright Student Expelled and Charged With Felonies for Science Experiment

The adults in this story should be charged with felonies for stupidity.  From the Washington Times Communities blog:
As Reason Magazine and WTSP.com in Florida report, “Meet Kiera Wilmot is a 16-year-old student in Bartow, Florida. Before last week, Bartow High School Principal Ron Pritchard told WTSP-TV, she had “never been in trouble before. Ever.”
Kiera Wilmont

Curious to experiment for an upcoming Science Fair, Wilmot mixed toilet bowl cleaner and aluminum foil in a tiny 8-ounce water bottle. The student was unsure what to expect, but heard from a friend the mixture would produce non-toxic smoke. The concoction caused the bottle top to pop off and, in fact, produce smoke.

Assistant Principal Dan Durham reportedly heard the noise, investigated and called the police. The arrest report can be reviewed here.

The chemicals were legal and no one was hurt, but the activity violated the school’s code of conduct, which mandates expulsion for any “student in possession of a bomb or explosive device…while at a school, a school activity or a school bus…unless it’s used as part of a school-related activity sanctioned by and conducted by a teacher.”

...

Polk County School administrators released a statement supporting their actions:

“Anytime a student makes a bad choice it is disappointing to us. Unfortunately, the incident that occurred at Bartow High School yesterday was a sercious breach of conduct. In order to maintain a safe and orderly learning environment, we simply must uphold our code of conduct rules. We urge our parents to join us in conveying the message that there are consequences to actions. We will not compromise the safety and security of our students and staff.”
Wilmot has apparently now been charged with two felonies, possession/discharge of a weapon on school property and discharging a destructive device,” according to Florida-based WTSP news. Both charges are felonies. The plan is to try her as an adult. As a convicted felon, of course she will be facing a far different future than had been expected from this bright young woman.

The Washington Times Communities blog proceeds to offer excellent commentary on the subject:
Kiera Wilmot’s story raises a series of troubling questions. This could happen to any student. Classmates, the Principal and the student herself clarified this was no act of malevolence, but school administrators and law enforcement pursued charges to ensure “safety and security”. Have this nation’s schools become such mindless, bureaucratic prisons that all reason is forfeit?
...

Zero tolerance policies can be effective, but all involved seem to indicate this was a mistake, an act of curiosity gone wrong. Does this not set a precedent that even if no one is injured, the very possibility of injury warrants ruining a 16-year old student’s life? Since when do innocent accidents warrant prison sentences?

How do Polk County bureaucrats have the power to ruin a child’s life over an honest mistake? Why are school administrators no longer serving their community and their students, but lording over schools like wardens? How are teachers expected to inspire and challenge students under such stifling conditions? Where is the community of Bartow in response to this overreaction that could result in a bright young woman being thrown into jail?

Silly risks should not be encouraged, but unreasonable, ridiculous responses like this send a frightening message to curious students: step out of line, make a mistake and you and your parent’s lives can be ruined. If this is the punishment for experimentation, how can we expect the current educational paradigm to produce more Ben Franklins, or Nicola Teslas?

Does America not need more scientists and engineers? Isn’t the reality of science perpetual failure until discovery? How many of the bright minds of tomorrow are stifled by fear of cruel and unusual punishment at the hands of bureaucrats? Should we emphasize that one bad decision determines a lifetime of punishment, such as being deemed a felonious criminal?

Perhaps the best punishment for this exceptional student would have been a lengthy assignment detailing safety measures. If necessary, perhaps an essay explaining what she learned with a thorough plan to not repeat risky experiments again without closer teacher supervision. Perhaps, if administrators were interested in their student’s future and less about the momentary thrill of exercising power over others, Wilmot could have been encouraged to pursue a track in science.
Schools across America should be places for students to explore their curiosity safely and wisely. Educating our students on precautionary measures when accidents occur cultivates wonder while minimizing risk. Reprimanding dangerous behavior appropriately should be our focus as an advanced, civilized society.

We should all be outraged when low-level bureaucrats reprimand accidental, harmless mistakes with life-destroying felony charges....

7 comments:

Hoosier in the Heartland said...

"Reprimanding dangerous behavior appropriately should be our focus as an advanced, civilized society."

Right on target, Paul.

Polk County is, after all, Florida "cracker country" and they sure are acting like intelligence (not to mention common sense) are still in short supply there.

Pete Boggs said...

If this story happened as told; this kid needs a legal hand / fund & Polk County needs a legal butt kicking.
The county's idiocracy is the true danger.

Indy Rob said...

It is stupid to send this dimbulb to jail, but it is also stupid to believe even for a minute that she just happened to pick two materials that would explode when mixed, even when she wants to explain it as a science fair project.

This is the sort of thing that never should be in the press, never should have charges brought and should be dealt with by the school without literally making a federal case of it.

Paul K. Ogden said...

Indy Rob, I don't know where you get the idea she is a "dimbulb." By all accounts she is an excellent student and very bright. The stories I've seen all say she'd heard it would cause a reaction...it wasn't just some random accident. Nobody ever claimed that.

There are very few people who have lived through their childhood who hasn't done experiments like this. Ever done put Mentos into a 2 liter of Coke?

Indy Rob said...

Paul, I am not sure that she is a dimbulb in all respects, but aluminium foil and drain cleaner are not things that are carried around by students, she would have had to get those materials from somewhere. These materials are not hard to obtain but there is some effort involved.

I really question the judgement of a "bright" student who takes these materials to school and performs her experiment there. I define that as being a dimbulb.

And if she is bright, she would have googled aluminium foil and drain cleaner, which returns multiple links to stories and videos showing what happens when those two are mixed.

Maybe she is bright, but mixing chemicals together (either she knew what would happen or she did not) while at school is not a rationale, considered action.

And felony charges are still absurd.

Cato said...

Indy Rob, not a word can be said in defense of the government.

This governmental conduct proves the country is dead.

bos daiwei said...

This is not a requirement: It is an implementation decision.
  cheap nfl jerseys|nfl jerseys free shipping